CJTC — The Center for Justice, Tolerance & Community University of California, Santa Cruz
CJTC — The Center for Justice, Tolerance & Community

Research and Community Projects


Globalizing Civil Society from the Inside Out

Globalizing Civil Society

Globalizing Civil Society is a joint project of the Center for Justice, Tolerance and Community and the Inter-American Forum.  Described in more detail below, the most recent product of this collaboration is Bringing Globalization Home: Portraits of Popular Education at the Global Local Junction.  This report documents how community-based organizations (CBOs) have added their voice to the debate around globalization, profiling four specific popular education efforts to connect the global-local dots though the creative use of curriculum, programs, games, and other tools.  Already in distribution, Bringing Globalization Home has been brought to good use, as local CBO's utilized and shared the publication at this year's World Social Forum in Brazil.  As a supplement to these profiles, the GCS project has also developed an internet clearinghouse launched in February, 2005, which includes more profiles, downloadable tools, games, and curriculum, and resources such as a bibliography, listings of popular education artists, and links. 


The Project
The Participants
The Partners
The Retreat: Overview
Project Advisors
Executive Summary
FTAA Information


The Project

In recent years, the social and economic impacts of globalization on community development and the environment has become increasingly apparent to community-based organizations (CBOs) in the U.S. Freer flows of goods and capital has been accompanied by rising workplace inequality and a spiraling competition for profitability that threatens the natural environment. A new global consumer culture celebrates the universality of the buyer and commodifies everything “ethnic” in advertising even as there is a simultaneous rise in anti-immigrant sentiment.

What is an appropriate local response to these trends? While officials claim that little can be done if we are to remain “competitive,” mass protest has accompanied the meetings of the WTO in Seattle, Geneva, and elsewhere. The connection of the global and local is being made but the voice of low-income communities in the U.S., particularly those of color, is often underrepresented in the debate.

Yet it is often these communities that are most affected. Recent research suggests that lower-income communities of color were the most negatively impacted by the implementation of the NAFTA agreement. One study tracing the effects of globalization at a local geographic level in Los Angeles found that those communities winning from international trade were 62 percent Anglo while people of color made up 84 percent of those living in the areas most negatively impacted by trade dynamics.

We have been asked by the Ford Foundation to develop and facilitate a process in which the perspective of such affected communities can be better infused into the globalization debate. We are specifically hosting two parallel convenings, one in California and one in Florida, that will:

  • Provide an opportunity for reflection on the impacts and possibilities of globalization to local leaders who frequently face other pressing concerns in distressed communities;
  • Allow these leaders to work together in a retreat-style setting to develop a working model/agenda for an “intentional learning community” focused on community-based organizations (CBOs) wishing to engage in globalization issues; and
  • Use this input to inform the foundation and philanthropic agendas about the capacity building needs of community groups as they relate to making global/local linkages.

[Executive Summary]

[Top of Page]


The Participants

We are specifically targeting those CBOs looking to understand the local impacts of globalization and devise strategies that build community wealth and power in the context of challenging and changing those impacts. Our definition of this is broad. Examples of this type of organizing might include creating new credit unions to manage remittance flows, creating alternative forms of media to voice local concerns about globalization, responding to toxic threats by targeting the whole global chain of production, setting standards on products and enforcing these in ways that build local industry and protect local environments, devising new strategies for the dissemination of information re the international economy to local groups, working to protect the rights of transnational migrants, developing positive responses by seizing on export opportunities and trade projects, etc.

While we will include select intermediaries that work on information analysis and dissemination, we are particularly interested in the participation of grassroots organizers, some of whom may be just getting involved in challenging transnational dynamics. We hope, in short, for “unusual suspects” who can better inform what sort of popular education tools might be most effective at engaging local communities and making the global-local link. We are also looking for those who wish to contribute to creating a positive space for transformational leadership, that is, wishing to engage in sharp debate with an eye toward developing a mutual understanding of pro-equity and pro-community responses to globalization.

[For A List of GCS Participants]

[Top of Page]


The Partners

This effort involves two Centers on opposite coasts of the United States, both based in regions that are being rapidly transformed by both international trade and migration. Both Centers are relatively new and have focused in the past on creating community and transnational forums, conducting social justice research, and providing training and educational opportunities for community leaders.

The East Coast partner, the Inter-American Forum, is a relatively new leadership and policy project dedicated to promoting a dynamic pro-community, pro-equity economic and trade policy agenda at the local, hemispheric and international level. The project is designed to serve as a forum for creative and innovative people dedicated to a) transcending and transforming the increasingly polarized public and policy discourse about globalization, regional economic integration, communities and social equity and b) creating a unique space for developing, highlighting and promoting new visions of trade and economic policy that places social equity, public interest and community at the center of the policy agenda.

The West Coast partner, the Center for Justice, Tolerance, and Community, is a research, policy, and education center devoted to issues of social justice. Established in January 2000, our research efforts currently fall into several categories, including the links between regional and community development, the dimensions of environmental inequity in the United States, and changing patterns of employment for low-wage U.S., particularly minority, workers. Perhaps the work most relevant to this project is our Summer Institute, Social Change Across Borders — a retreat for grassroots leaders specifically intended to create a space for Latin American and Latino/a organizers from CBOs and NGOs to reflect, network, and understand better how globalization affects their varied social and environmental justice agendas. See http://lals.ucsc.edu/summer_institute for more information.


Manuel Pastor, Jr.
Professor, Latin American & Latino Studies
Director, Center for Justice, Tolerance and Community
Telephone: 831-459-5919
Facsimile: 831-459-3125
Email: mpastor@ucsc.edu

Tanya Dawkins
Founder and Director
Inter-American Forum
Telephone: 305-377-4484, Extension 30
Facsimile: 305-377-4485
Email: dawkinst@mindspring.com or tdawkins@collinscenter.org

[Top of Page]


The Retreat: Overview

Friday: Building Community

The participants arrive by early evening on Friday and will have a chance to get to know each other better through a Conocimiento that encourages exchange at both professional and personal levels.

  • Who are the members of our community? (self introductions)
  • What expectations do we have & what contributions do we each want to make to this conversation?
  • Who do we each need each other to be in order for this space to be positive, progressive and transformative?


Saturday: Debating Globalization and Mobilizing for Change

The morning will involve a broad interactive session on the benefits and challenges of globalization working together to build an overall definition, including points of agreement and disagreement, and alternatives.

The afternoon focuses on questions of mobilization. This is an opportunity for participants to share their work, with facilitators helping to gather comments, guide discussion, and generate a preliminary synthesis of the challenges and lessons learned. The focus here is on movement-building — what are the current approaches of social movements organizing around globalization and what are the critical gaps in terms of representation, our strategies.

There will be an evening speaker and/or a cultural event.


Sunday: Creating a Learning Community, Popular Education & Next Steps

The morning will focus on a) exploring the concept of creating a learning community around the issues of globalization; b) discussion of the principles of popular education and experiences in doing this both with regard to globalization, economic justice, environmental justice, and other issues.

The early afternoon will be organized around a broad discussion of the next steps involved in forming a learning community and generating popular education addressing critical questions like:

  • What sort of learning community and education agenda would we suggest based on this conversation?
  • What kind of commitments and experiences would it take for you to want to participate in this learning community?
  • What implications does this have for the philanthropic community?

Participants depart following the closing session.

[Top of Page]


Project Advisors

Fred Azcarate
Jobs with Justice

John Cavanagh
Institute for Policy Studies

Connie García
Environmental Health Coalition

Debra Harry
Indigenous Peoples Council on Biocolonialism

Benetta Johnson
Alameda Corridor Jobs Coalition

George Kourous
InterHemispheric Resource Center

Peggy Saika
Asian Pacifics in Philanthropy

Julie Su
Asian Pacific American Legal Center

Dan Swinney
Center for Labor and Community Research

Catherine Tactaquin
National Network for Immigrant Rights

Anthony Thigpenn

Mark Toney
Center for Third World Organizing

Lori Villarosa
Mott Foundation

Kent Wong
UCLA Labor Center

[Top of Page]


The Root Cause

The Root Cause is a community-based coalition of organizations building grassroots resistance to the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA). Several of the groups involved in the GCS project have played a role in this initiative.

For more information on the FTAA take a look at http://therootcause.com

[Top of Page]



"Bringing Globalization Home: Portraits of Popular Education at the Global-Local Junction"
February 2005
A joint project of: The Center for Justice, Tolerance, and Community and the Inter-American Forum at the Collins Center for Public Policy in Miami, Florida.

Color Lines vol. 7, no. 2, Summer 2004
"Bringing Globalization Home"
By Manuel Pastor and Tony LoPresti

Posted on Mon, Feb. 02, 2004
"Seeds of reform are sown in India"
By Eduardo Moncada, Tony LoPresti, and Manuel Pastor

January 8, 2004
"What to Make of Miami"
by Mike Prokosch and Tony LoPresti
December 1, 2003
"Mobilizing Miami"
by Manuel Pastor and Tony LoPresti

[Top of Page]